An irrational idea is an idea that is false in a logical setting.
Subject: Idea of Ideas.
Irrational ideas are not currently anchored in empirical evidence or rational proof. An irrational idea is not automatically worthless either. It may be speculative, fictional, symbolic, spiritual, creative, untested, or inconsistent. Unicorns, Valhalla, and speculative theories begin here. In TST, irrational ideas are held with humility, if held at all.
-
Michael Alan Prestwood.
-
2024.
Life becomes calmer when you stop demanding perfect certainty. Your impressions are imperfect, but they are enough to help you learn and grow.
Subject: Empiricism.
To live well, accepting that your picture of reality is always being assembled. You will not see everything clearly at once, and that is okay. Pay attention, stay humble, and keep refining. Wisdom grows when you let experience teach you without pretending you already know the whole truth.
When encountering new information, first ask: is it empirical, rational, or irrational? Then think about how much you believe it.
Subject: Idea of Ideas.
After you categorize an idea as empirically true, rationally true, or currently false, you can then start to calibrate your belief in it. Even ideas in the irrational category may deserve some degree of belief, depending on the evidence, context, and the limits of what is currently known.
An idea is irrationally false when it lacks empirical support, fails logical consistency, or depends on unverified or disproven claims.
Subject: Idea of Ideas.
Irrationally false does not always mean ridiculous. Some ideas are disproven. Others are merely untested, untestable, speculative, fictional, or built on shaky assumptions. In TST, such ideas are not treated as known truth. They may be explored, imagined, or held personally, but they remain outside justified public truth.
From History: The Idea of the Unknowable Dao.
If you embrace that absolute truth exists only in objective reality, then our human claims can remain provisional and always open to refinement, correction, and falsification.
Subject: Absolute Truth.
Remember absolute truth belongs to the material world as it is. Humans never hold it absolutely. You construct empirical and rational descriptions that align with reality or not, and then you believe each one with a degree of confidence. Each of your claims remains open to testing and revision. Even your strongest conclusions are provisional: true until disproven, not true beyond challenge.
Remember, all your ideas start as speculation. Even Einstein’s theory of relativity began as an irrational idea: untested, uncertain, and waiting for reality to answer back.
Subject: Idea of Ideas.
All your discoveries begin as irrational, not wrong, just untested. So make sure you reserve judgement of even your own ideas until proven. In 1915, Einstein’s general relativity challenged Newton’s gravity as a fresh idea. Only after the 1919 eclipse confirmed its predictions did it become empirical truth.
Good common knowledge is the Grand Rational Framework. It is our common-floor public belief, and it evolves knowledge anchored to the material world, where only evidence-grounded reasoning reshapes what we collectively treat as true.
Subject: Knowledge.
If we can all agree that the Grand Rational Framework is our science-first common sense, where we observe, test, and reason, we can remain honest about what cannot be. Public belief does not deny emotion, intuition, or confidence; it simply refuses to treat them as evidence.
This is your life. Embrace the beliefs you understand and believe in, not just the beliefs you inherited.
Subject: Personal Belief.
Live your life in a way that fully understands your own beliefs. Personal belief forms through public belief, tribal influence, and your own worldview. We do not begin as blank choosers, nor are we merely passive products of society. We are born into a family language, religion, and philosophy.
From History: The abstractions of life..
Schemas are mental categories across frameworks that simplify life. To think well, challenge them. Keep what fits, update or drop the rest.
Subject: Frameworks.
Schemas shape what feels normal, right, threatening, or familiar. Compare the same schema across family, religion, work, politics, and culture. The subtle differences can bring wisdom. Some inherited templates resonate with your authentic self; others were simply handed to you. To think well, keep what fits and revise what does not.
Math is discovered in the structure of the Material World but invented in the symbolic systems minds use to describe that structure.
Subject: Idea of Ideas.
If math refers to the real patterns and relations built into reality, then it was discovered. If it refers to the symbols, notation, and systems of thought used to describe those patterns, then it was invented. In TST terms, the structure belongs to the Material World, while mathematics as a formal language belongs to the realm of Ideas.