Phil • Cr. Think • Science • Hist • …
TST PRACTICE

By Philosopher Michael Alan Prestwood

How does TST handle the Law of Noncontradiction?

☐ Listened
☑ Listened
You’ve listened to this 0 times.
You’ve read this 0 times.
~ < 1 of audio

How does TST handle the Law of Noncontradiction?

The Law of Noncontradiction states that a thing cannot both be and not be, at the same time and in the same respect. A foundational principle of classical logic, it helps us establish binary truth. In thinking well, it helps us identify contradictions. Without it, two contradictory claims could be accepted as true, undermining our ability to reason.

“Nothing can be and not be.”

The Law of Noncontradiction stems directly from reality. But how do we establish that reality never instantiates contradictions without already relying on the Law of Noncontradiction? The answer is induction. We observe nature, identify patterns, and build ideas that describe those patterns. Across countless observations, reality has consistently supported the Law of Noncontradiction. Show me a reliable and reproducible case in nature where it’s wrong, and I’ll overturn current understanding of logic.

A philosopher might object that induction cannot establish a universal law with absolute certainty. Fair enough. Hume was right about its limits. But we can still rely on induction even if we don’t possess absolute truth. This law is grounded in the structure of reality, not a rule that human minds impose upon nature. Between the split of reality and our ideas about it, reality comes first.

Our logic describes reality, it’s not something nature must obey. Do not place human thought before reality, a form of anthropocentrism one should avoid. We use logic to interpret observations because it has proven reliable, not because we possess absolute truth. Induction justifies our confidence without guaranteeing certainty. If reality provides reproducible evidence that contradicts a framework, we revise the framework. We do not revise nature.

Reality is the standard. Logic is one of our best tools for describing it.

Here’s your premium extra.

The Law of Noncontradiction states that something cannot both be and not be, at the same time and in the same respect.
Subject: Law of Noncontradiction.
The Law of Noncontradiction works because it describes reality. Reality does not instantiate the same thing as both being and not-being, in the same respect, at the same time. We observe nature, identify patterns, and build rational ideas that describe those patterns. Across countless observations, reality has consistently supported the principle. Show me a reliable and reproducible case in nature where it’s wrong, and I’ll revise or overturn our understanding of logic.

Flashcard.

What law says something cannot both be and not be, at the same time and in the same respect?.
Answer. Law of Noncontradiction.


That Reasoning FAQ, 

was first published on TST 1 month ago.
This tidbit is part of the broader TST project.
Tidbits make it possible to build slowly and honestly, without losing track of where an idea came from.

The end!

Scroll to Top