Phil • Cr. Think • Science • Hist • …
TST PRACTICE

By Philosopher Michael Alan Prestwood

Wisdom Builder

Three Tidbit Stories

Topic:
Logical Fallacies
Timeless ideas at the intersections of science, philosophy, critical thinking, and history.

Logical Fallacies.

3 random tidbit stories in about 3 minutes.

Idea 1.

A Logical Fallacies Story.

66.04 Million years ago (K–Pg extinction)

By the final stretch of the Cretaceous, the last toothed birds still came in more than one form. Some were Ichthyornis-like, strong-flying coastal birds with teeth set farther back in the jaws, giving them a strange mix of modern bird body and ancient reptilian mouth. Others were Hesperornis-like, large diving birds that had also kept teeth but had taken a very different path, becoming specialized swimmers rather than strong fliers. Alongside them were other archaic bird groups, including enantiornithines, some of which were hawk-sized and likely predatory or at least strongly grasping-footed. So the last toothed birds were not one fading little remnant. They were part of a broader, still-varied Late Cretaceous bird world.

And the birds that vanished were not only the toothed ones. Many toothless birds also disappeared at 66 million years ago. The great Mesozoic bird branch Enantiornithes went extinct, even though many of them looked surprisingly birdlike to modern eyes, and at least some had already evolved beaks and reduced or absent teeth. Latest Cretaceous bird faunas also included a wider mix of small archaic forms than the few famous names suggest. In other words, the extinction did not just prune away “primitive toothed birds.” It erased a much richer avian experiment, including many toothless birds that simply belonged to the wrong branches.

The future story is both bleak and hopeful. As far as current evidence shows, no toothed bird lineage made it through the K–Pg extinction, and the survivors belonged to crown birds, the branch that leads to living birds. We can say with confidence that at least one crown-bird lineage survived, because birds are still here. Beyond that, the strongest current picture is that the ancestors of the three great modern bird divisions—Palaeognathae, Galloanserae, and Neoaves—were already present or took shape very near that boundary, making it very likely that three major surviving branches crossed into the Paleogene. Researchers also argue that the impact devastated forests globally, so the survivors were probably small, mostly ground-dwelling or shore-associated birds rather than tree specialists. We are still looking, and the fossils are frustratingly sparse, but the broad story is now fairly clear: most bird branches died, and a small crown-bird remnant inherited the Earth.

I wrote that Logical Fallacies Story, 

and posted it to TST 8 months ago.

 

Idea 2.

A Logical Fallacies Story.

Born 1806, he lived to see 1873.
9 Generations Ago

30 Philosophers, Chapter 29: Mill and Utilitarianism. 

John Stuart Mill was born on May 20, 1806, in London, to James Mill, a Scottish-born philosopher and economist, and Harriet Barrow. His Greatest Happiness Principle lies at the core of utilitarianism, advocating for actions that maximize utility, generally understood as producing the greatest well-being for the most people, but how do you measure or evaluate this “utility” or “happiness?”

On May 8, 1873, at age 66, surrounded by a few friends and his stepdaughter Helen, John Stuart Mill took his final breaths.

 

 

I wrote that Logical Fallacies Story, 

and posted it to TST 3 years ago.

 

Idea 3.

A Logical Fallacies Quote.

In 1859, Charles Darwin published On the Origin of Species, and near the end of that groundbreaking book he slipped in one of the most famous lines in the history of human origins:

“Light will be thrown on the origin of man and his history.”

It was brief, almost restrained, but that was part of its power. Darwin’s main purpose in Origin was to argue for evolution by natural selection across life as a whole, not to turn the book into a direct fight over human ancestry. So he said just enough. He planted the idea carefully, knowing full well that readers would understand the implication.

That is why the line feels so prophetic. Darwin clearly saw where his theory pointed: humans were not exempt from nature’s story. In 1859, the cultural and religious resistance would have been fierce, and Darwin was too careful a thinker to outrun what his audience could absorb in one leap. So he brought people as far as he could, then left the door open. Years later, in The Descent of Man in 1871, he walked through that door more directly. Even then, the fossil evidence was still sparse, but Darwin had already seen the outline of the truth before much of the world was ready to face it.

That one sentence was the opening bell of paleoanthropology. It didn’t create the field, but it announced the hunt. It told future scientists that human origins belonged inside science. Fossils, anatomy, geology, and later genetics would all rush into that opening.

I wrote that Logical Fallacies Quote, 

and posted it to TST 8 months ago.

 

The end. Refresh for another set.

Scroll to Top