Phil • Cr. Think • Science • Hist • …
TST PRACTICE

By Philosopher Michael Alan Prestwood

Wisdom Builder

Three Tidbit Stories

Ancient Humans.

3 random tidbit stories in about 3 minutes.

Idea 1.

A Ancient Humans Story.

1853

Discovered in 1853 by British archaeologist Austen Henry Layard, the Epic of Gilgamesh’s flood story had been lost for millennia. Layard uncovered a library of clay tablets in the ruins of Nineveh, in modern-day Iraq. This story predates the earliest written version of the biblical flood story by at least 400 years and likely by more than a millennium. Both narratives tell essentially the same story, with different character names, minor variations, and a shift from multiple gods to a single god. The story of Noah’s Ark, set around 600-500 BCE, is a retelling of a much older Sumerian story from about 2550 BCE featuring the character Ziusudra.

I wrote that Ancient Humans Story, 

and posted it to TST 2 years ago.

 

Idea 2.

A Ancient Humans Story.

66 Million BCE
Grasping hand and flexible ankles

Within mammals, only primates have binocular vision, grasping hands, and flat nails–instead of claws. Purgatorius might have had all three earning it the earliest known proto-primate label. It lived in Eastern Montana about 66 million years ago during the very last years of the Cretaceous period. It lived through the K-T extinction event and the extinction of dinosaurs.

Class: Mammal; Early Proto-Primate
Time Period: Late Cretaceous to the early Paleocene
Diet: Likely Frugivorous (fruits) / Insectivorous (insects)

I wrote that Ancient Humans Story, 

and posted it to TST 5 years ago.

 

Idea 3.

A Ancient Humans FAQ.

Counterfactuals are interesting to philosophers because they ask us to think about what would be true if something had been different. They live in the world of “what if.” 

What if kangaroos had no tails, would they topple over?

Which you can turn into a statement like this:

If kangaroos had no tails, they would topple over.

All this talk about kangaroos became famous with the American philosopher David K. Lewis, who visited Australia frequently. He famously handled counterfactuals using possible worlds. In his view, you would evaluate those statements by looking at the closest possible worlds where kangaroos have no tails. If, in those nearby worlds, kangaroos topple over, then the counterfactual is true. Lewis’s approach asks us to temporarily grant an imagined premise.

The Idea of Ideas handles counterfactuals more simply. It treats them like any other idea. The word “if” does not give an idea special permission to pretend to be true. Furthermore, counterfactuals are rational or irrational ideas. They are never empirical because they never describe the material world directly.

Here is an example of a rational counterfactual:

If the room had no oxygen, the fire would not have started.

This is rational because it describes a possible world that rests on a directly testable and repeatable relationship in the material world. Fire requires oxygen.

Now, take this rational idea:

If something that is one inch long were two inches long, it would be twice as long.

This is a counterfactual because it reimagines one inch things.

As one final example, let’s take a look at a speculative counterfactual.

In a world where kangaroos had no tails, they would topple over.

This is speculative because the claim depends on an imagined world that is not known to exist but also cannot be disproven.

I wrote that Ancient Humans FAQ, 

and posted it to TST 5 months ago.

 

The end. Refresh for another set.

Scroll to Top