1-MINUTE HOT TOPIC

How do we know bloodletting doesn’t work?

By Michael Alan Prestwood

Author and Natural Philosopher

Follow On Facebook and Youtube!
Reading Material: 
Videos: 
False Cause Fallacy
Logical Fallacies < Four Mind Traps < TST Framework < Critical Thinking
Share :
Email
Print

How do we know bloodletting doesn’t work?

This is a great example of the false cause logical fallacy—because for over 4,000 years, bloodletting was widely accepted as a cure for illness. Imagine the shock professional doctors must have felt when, in the 1830s, studies showed that bloodletting didn’t help—it actually harmed patients.

Bloodletting was popular because some patients seemed to get better afterward. But that improvement had nothing to do with blood loss. This was just a false cause fallacy in action: the doctors assumed the treatment caused recovery, but it was really the body healing itself.

Science is a process, not a set of fixed facts. Even after discovering that bloodletting didn’t work, it took decades to persuade doctors, and many clung to the old ways. Change didn’t fully take hold until a new generation of doctors could “hear” the truth and accept evidence over tradition.

So, how do we know bloodletting doesn’t work? We proved it through observation and experimentation—key to avoiding false cause fallacies.

Share this on...

Comments

Join the Conversation! Currently logged out.

KEEP GOING!

Just 4 minutes a week.

Weekly Wisdom Builder 
4 minutes of leisurely exploration.
February 12, 2025 Edition
Quote of the Week
Time Left: 

Email Notification
Subscribe to our Weekly Wisdom BuilderIt’s Free! No ads! No catches! One email each Thursday.

Exactly what the world needs RIGHT NOW!
Wisdom at the crossroads of knowledge.

Wisdom emerges from the consistent exploration of the intersections of philosophy, science, critical thinking, and history.

NEW BOOK! NOW AVAILABLE!!

30 Philosophers: A New Look at Timeless Ideas

by Michael Alan Prestwood
The story of the history of our best ideas!
divider-red-swirls1.png
Scroll to Top